Making the Perfect Record: From Inscription to Impression in Early Magnetic Recording

About

Abstract

Intended for audiences across the intersections of literary criticism and comparative media studies, this essay highlights how magnetic recording was affiliated with permanent, immaterial sound during its first six decades (1870–1930). Oberlin Smith (1878) initially framed it as a scratch-free alternative to Menlo Park inscription methods and Edison’s tinfoil phonograph. Later, Valdemar Poulsen’s research on the telegraphone, including his demonstration of it at the 1900 Paris Exhibition, suggested that even then magnetic recordings could be erased and re-recorded. Intended as a mechanism for writing the voice from a distance, the telegraphone—which could only store approximately four minutes of barely audible sound—was an economic failure in the United States and Europe, reduced solely to military use by 1917. 

However, author and amateur criminologist, Arthur B. Reeve, did write about the telegraphone during the 1910s and 1920s. Spanning magazines, cartoons, film, and radio, Reeve’s incredibly popular science fiction detective tales didactically introduced audiences to the presumably magical affordances of the relatively unknown telegraphone, mixing technical specifications with paranoia about the infallibility of forensic science and disembodied voices forever recorded on wire. Despite the telegraphone’s economic failure, the magnetic aura of imperceptible audio and immaterial sound still gained traction in consumer markets well before tape in the 1940s. Through the use of the Scalar platform, this essay unpacks the often ignored, pre-1940s history of magnetic recording, with particular attention to how—through an interweaving of print fiction, sound transduction, storage media, audio playback, and visual culture—early magnetic recording materialized. In so doing, the essay offers scholars of both new and old media a sense of how we might better historicize the ostensible permanence and immateriality of contemporary data cultures and their digital economies.

This essay is part of the "New Media" special issue of American Literature (volume 85, number 4, December 2013). See http://10.1215/00029831-2370230. Version 1 of the site is (c) 2013 by Duke University Press.

Acknowledgements

Technical Information 



Fair use, PDF, TXT, RDF, GitHub, JSON, RDF, Images, and HTML


This page has paths:

  1. Making the Perfect Record Jentery Sayers

Contents of this path:

  1. Introduction
  2. The Spirit of Sound
  3. The Telegraphone
  4. Prehistory for Today's Magnetic Media
  5. Responding to Edison's Noise
  6. Smith's Projected Design
  7. Fidelity and Deceit
  8. Not a Worthwhile Investment
  9. Selling the Weird Instrument
  10. Leave a Message
  11. A Rewritable Medium
  12. Remediating the Telephone
  13. Exhibiting the Telegraphone
  14. Mystifying the Technical Particulars
  15. The Mechanical Arts
  16. Imagining Applications
  17. Faith in the Device
  18. Reeve's Scientific Detective Fiction
  19. The Erudite, Loquacious Polymath
  20. Reeve's Scientific Realism
  21. The Modern Detective
  22. From Print to Film and Radio
  23. I Learned Their Methods
  24. Merely a Validation Machine
  25. Learning about Magnetic Recording through Fiction
  26. Enculturating Listening and Memory
  27. Speculative Determinism
  28. Before the Hard Drive
  29. No Neat Distinctions between Genres
  30. The Perfect Record and Plausible Denial
  31. References

This page references: