Spectacles of Agency and Desire: Dance Histories and the Burlesque Stage Main Menu

Second-Hand Pleasure: Bettie Page's Bondage Films

5977
Erotic films are also a major facet of the Burlesque umbrella.  These films bring up ideas and questions about second-hand pleasure; pleasure that is captured on camera for later “usage.” Audre Lorde argues that the erotic cannot be felt second hand, and that the use of the erotic, without the consent of the used is abuse (Lorde 59). In addition to Lorde’s statement about the illegitimacy of second-hand eroticism, Nadine Strossen, in her essay, "The Feminist Critique of 'the' Feminist Critique of Pornography," articulates how the Dworkin-Mackinnon ideology surrounding pornography suggests that women are inherently incapable of giving truly voluntary, informed consent to pose for sexually explicit pictures” (Strossen 1137) because of the nature of our patriarchal society. But this ideology epitomizes the patronizing misogyny that it seeks to critique, stripping women of the possible desire to engage in such actions involving and exposing their sexuality.  Bettie Page and her brand of erotic films (bondage), most often directed by filmmaker Irving Klaw, exemplify eroticism that is intended to be felt second hand, (similar to pornography). 
 
While Lorde’s claim that eroticism cannot be felt second-hand, and the Dworkin-Mackinnon ideology that women inherently cannot consent to pose explicitly would both label Bettie Page’s work in Klaw’s Bondage films as degrading abuse, Page’s performance of bondage and masochism exposes a sexuality that challenges the policing of women’s sexual and erotic potential.  Similarly, Nadine Strossen articulates that the “subversive quality of “pornography” challenges the entire status quo, including social structures that inhibit women’s freedom” (Strossen 1133).  Bettie Page’s bondage films portray women, including herself, wearing highly sexualized outfits, (leather and lacey undergarments, high heels, and stockings).  They tie each other up, spank each other, trap each other, roll around and fight on the floor.  These violent yet sexual acts performed for the camera may appear to be degrading to some.  But as Strossen explains, what “one woman views as misogynistic may be viewed by another as reaffirming her desires and her equality” (1130).  Denying Page’s pleasure in her bondage performance, and denying that women could be empowered by this portrayal of dominance and sexuality, limits the extent of women’s desires.  The sexual dominance that Page’s performance exhibits broadens the scope of female sexuality to the public eye.
Works Cited:

Bettie Page Reveals All. Dir. Mark Mori. Writ. Douglass Miller. Single Spark Pictures. 2012. Film.

Lorde, Audre. “Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power.” Sister Outsider. Freedom, CA: The Crossing Press, 2007. 53-59. Print.

Strossen, Nadine. “A Feminist Critique of "the" Feminist Critique of Pornography.” Virginia Law Review 79.5 (1993): 1099–1190. Web. 21 October 2015.

This page has paths:

  1. Pleasure in Burlesque: Power in the Erotic and Presence Harmony Bench

This page has tags:

  1. "Un-Ruly" Rachel Sigrid Freeburg
  2. Subject vs. Object Rachel Sigrid Freeburg
  3. Lilianna Kane Lilianna Kane
  4. Empowering or Demeaning? Rachel Sigrid Freeburg

This page references: