Making the Perfect Record: From Inscription to Impression in Early Magnetic Recording

Offended Smith's Ears

Smith was not the only one with a critique. For instance, see the Telegraphic Journal and Electrical Review in 1879: “Edison’s phonograph, as now constructed, is in several important respects defective. For example, the time of recording the sound on the apparatus is proportioned to the size of the barrel. The necessity of wrapping the barrel with foil does not permit of the conservation of speech, and by reason of its flimsy character only allows of several repetitions” (“A New Phonograph”).

(This note comments on the page titled, "Responding to Edison's Noise," as well as the attached image titled, "Edison's 19th-Century Phonograph (1888).")

This page has paths:

This page references: