Paintings of Chinese punishment were a unique category of export art. As traditional Chinese painters were not interested in presenting violent scenes, these punishment paintings did not correspond with traditional Chinese aesthetic values, and clearly deviated from “the rule of morality and benevolence”(
德治仁政), which was highly emphasized and promoted by Chinese rulers and taste-makers. The paintings of Chinese penalty sold at the port of Guangzhou, however, are realistic and life-like, and “the true reflection of the social life at the time. These pictures were not only desired by Westerners, but also widely used in public prints in Europe, when news stories greatly affect European impression of China.[4] These paintings, along with the narratives of the Qing legal system, presented the Chinese as unusually cruel. The impact of this art should be discussed in the context of both European and Chinese societies.
________________________
[3] Nancy Ellen Davis, “The American China Trade, 1784-1844: Products for the Middle Class.” George Washington University Dissertation, 1987
[4] Cun,Jie 存洁. Shijiu shiji Zhongguo waixiao tongcao shuicai hua yanjiu 十九世纪中国外销通草水彩画研究. Shanghai上海: Guji chuban she古籍出版社, 2008.p. 62: “是當時社會生活的真實寫照,...不僅成為西方人士競相爭閱的圖畫,也被廣泛用在歐洲的大眾印刷品中,圖解當時的新聞故事,大大影響著歐洲人對中國的印象.”