Housing Inequality in AmericaMain MenuThe Generational Illusion: An EssayAn Essay by Collin AndrewsEnvironmental Racism: How Residential Segregation Shapes Environmental InequalityHistoric Preservation Coast to CoastTitle PageNative American Housing: How Poor Housing Harms Indigenous HealthHow Poor Housing Harms Indigenous HealthPets & Housing: It's "Ruff" by Katie ClineHow NIMBYism Exacerbates Housing InequalityWhere's the Wealth!How Housing Discrimination has led to racial wealth inequality in the United StatesImmigrant Housing Inequality in AmericaIswat JinadSurveillance InequalityAn investigation into how poor communities are oversurveilled creating a cycle of more targeted and aggressive forms of surveillance for them and those around them.Post-WWII Urban Flight and the Birth of the SuburbsHousing Discrimination in Suburban AmericaRace, Repressive State Apparatus, and Homelessness: From Colonialism to COVID-19Tina NandiHousing Inequality and Access to Quality EducationMQ: Title PageVisualizing racial housing discriminationSplash page for path that includes interactive resources regarding racial housing discriminationProject information and creditsAndy Schocket278555063cc66428c8eadf42f48d412091c5aaf9Melissa Laddab8653014603439710b65435181f2130cee53400Andrew Bartelc9a57442f34fea7858b734ce98f4ec79bd5565b0Collin Andrewsf69afa6ae7fb0f33058b9e0cb476f7451a667cefTina Nandi6e38643c2c1510534cce4e954f0eeb8108bce699Iswat Jinad196dd805bf51f7a46fbf2d94ab069e97fc004d75Marcus Harris7e23857364c2363b25872718aea81323bdd37773James Cousinoe9398a1542d344c824ddaaf967819ae589cd2b61Katie Cline512add1943f75cbd770d4788dcdea90b706922c4Trisha A Bonham7fa13b399c9331700d719225b96f3bf9e54c4570Rene Oswald Ayalac01cc7385c24c3926f2f03a40860f6a4f703f410Kristine Ketel826fdfc33a24cff2c1e0ab79396dd2ae2bae3ed9Morgan Quinleyc8a47798c223cced64347bc9a7d80f6a64402e45
Restrictive covenant in Bowling Green
12022-12-03T07:26:44-08:00Andy Schocket278555063cc66428c8eadf42f48d412091c5aaf9412371Copy of deed including language prohibiting occupation of property "by a colored person"plain2022-12-03T07:26:45-08:00Andy Schocket278555063cc66428c8eadf42f48d412091c5aaf9
This page is referenced by:
12022-11-29T13:36:22-08:00AS: Cruel Covenants35Provides interactive resources concerning the practice of restrictive racial covenants on real estate deeds.plain2022-12-06T17:07:56-08:00If redlining showed the power of the federal government to shape housing policy by race, restrictive covenants showed how individuals, developers, and realtors could insert race at the property-by-property level.
Because these covenants could be inserted into property deeds—both for individual properties and sometimes for entire developments—they occurred just about everywhere in the United States, from big cities to small towns.
Even here, in Bowling Green, Ohio—as the circled text indicates in the deed on the right.
However, the text of those deeds is almost nowhere digitized on a whole-scale basis. There is no national map of properties with restrictive covenants. The only way to find them, in most places, is to look at individual deeds in county recorders' offices. To make a digital resource aggregating them, they have to be found one-by-one, and entered individually.
Still, a few projects have successfully mapped restrictive covenants.
Not surprisingly, restricted covenants blanketed our nation's capital city. Prologue DC, a group of Washington, DC-based historians, has produced Mapping Segregation DC.
The University of Washington's Seattle Civil Rights & Labor History Project has created Segregated Seattle, detailing the history of restrictive covenants in the U.S. northwest's largest city.
The nation's "Second City" was also the site of tens of thousands of such agreements. Digital Chicago, a joint venture between Lake Forest College and the Chicago History Museum, has constructed an interactive map of restrictive covenants in that city. To see the implementation of these over time, move the slider at the bottom of the frame.
Perhaps the most work has been done on St. Louis. The Metropolitan St. Louis Equal housing & Opportunity Council has produced an interactive map, as has Colin Gordon at the University of Iowa. NPR hastwice reported on this story, and perhaps most fascinating is a video timeline produced by St. Louis Public Radio.
As wonderful as they are, there are two challenges with these maps. First, they only cover a few big cities. And, those cities were also subject to redlining, which also shaped their history, making measuring the effect of these covenants more difficult. We know a lot less about the rest of the country, especially suburban and rural areas that were not covered by redlining.
In 1940, the Supreme Court ruled that racial restrictive covenants were not enforceable. That mostly ended the practice. But once a clause is in a deed, even an unenforceable clause, it stays in unless the owners go through the legal process to change it. As NPR explains, there may be millions of such deeds that still include this language, even if that language is no longer legally binding.