The Vulnerability of Human Emotion: An Effective Marketing Strategy in Medicine Trade Cards
With the rapid surge of pharmaceutical companies in the late 19th century, many companies looked toward patent medicine trade cards as a means of advertising their products directly to consumers. Pain medication in particular became a very lucrative market to enter and companies had to find ways to stand out and separate themselves from the competition. As seen with the cards in this set, one effective strategy that many companies adopted was appealing to the human emotion through various depictions of children or affection. These various portrayals of human emotion can be very captivating and attention-grabbing to the immediate customer which explains its popularity as a marketing strategy.
In regards to medical ephemera, it is also important to note that all of these cards in this collection represent irregular/alternative medicine. Perry Davis's card advertises a pain medication that is made from pure vegetables, Minard's company advertises a "liniment" which is a topical ointment used to ease pain stiffness, and Sura Cura's company advertises another topical product that is capable of purifying blood and skin in conjunction to relieving pain.
In Perry Davis’s trade card, the immediate elements that stick out are the many baby angels that dominate the foreground of the card. Children are the epitome of innocence and purity and to most humans, it is something that we all have a “soft side” for. Additionally, the flower petals that the leading baby is dropping may symbolize love, affection, and purity. Although the Perry Davis company is advertising a pain killer, a relatively negative feeling that humans avoid, the depictions of innocence and love from the babies juxtaposes and deters from the problems that the product seeks out to solve. Perry Davis’s product is also vegetable-based which is more along the lines of alternative medicine and is a large component as to what separates them from other pharmaceutical companies.
On the other hand, Minard's company takes a slightly different approach by choosing a subject that starkly juxtaposes the subject of Perry Davis’s card. Rather than opting for depictions of love and affection as seen with the smiling babies and flowers, Minard’s company chose the “Prince of Wails” as the main subject which appears to be a young baby who is frightful as he grips onto a furry creature. Regardless, this is still an effective marketing strategy as the Minard company chose to appeal to emotions of fear and pain as embodied by the baby who is in visible distraught. As humans, we can relate and easily sympathize with the fearful baby which captures the attention of consumers who may ultimately be more inclined to purchase the product.
The Sura Cura company also capitalizes on the vulnerability of human emotion as a marketing strategy, however, instead of using children, they used two adults showing affection towards one another. Given how the depictions of youth was a common theme across many trade cards, the Sura Cura company may have wanted to take a different approach towards appealing to consumer emotions with strong depictions of love and romance as the center of their advertising campaign. As opposed to the Perry Davis card, there is less “noise” on the card as Sura Cura took a more simplistic approach with less design elements and background. Similar to Minard’s Liniment, the audience’s attention is diverted towards the single subject in the center.
All in all, the vulnerability of human emotion was a popular means of advertising that many pharmaceutical companies capitalized on when trying to sell their products. These three cards are just a small sample size of how companies have appealed to consumer emotion whether that be through depictions of children or adults displaying affection. Though the success of these companies through quantifiable metrics may not exist, the legacy that these medical ephemera gives us a glimpse into the prominent marketing strategies and the consumer landscape of the late 19th century.
This page has paths:
- The Children of Medicine: An Appeal to Consumer Emotions Chien-Ling Liu Zeleny