America's Pastime: Patent Medicine Trade Cards on Pain

Marketing Language and Its Evolutions Through Time in Patent Medicine Trade Cards

"Ramon's nerve & bone oil" is an example of what is likely an earlier patent medicine trade card. The primary evidence is found in the word use and claims that the advertisement makes. The most important and telling word here is the use of "cures", it is not used precisely, it is arguably a wild claim. Additionally, the things the trade card claims to "cure" are not what would be considered a curable illness or condition - alleviated pain is different from curing it. In early examples of patent medicine trade cards, which evidence points to this example being, there was no regulation for the claims that could be made in these advertisements. Almost equally importantly, the expectations and knowledge of the consumer were different. Consumers likely took this for face value and there were no protections in place for outright falsehoods being claimed on these advertisements. These two apects are the primary evidence for its relative production date relative to other cards included on this page, but alongside this is the visual simplicity and lack of eye popping color that would become a staple of cards.

The second card, Risley's Extract is an example of what is likely a later card than Ramon's Nerve and Bone Oil. The largest clue in favor of this as discussed previously is the different word use. As is clear on the back of this card, the use of the word "for" is prominent and the card completely avoids the word "cure" alltogether. There is no clear date of creation of any of these cards, but the likely reason for the shift is either regulation that affects what claims these cards are allowed to make, or a shift in consumer interests, the former more likely. The style of this card's illustration is quite different as well, this card being more intricate and colorful. This is less so evidence of any relative period in time and moreso evidence of a card that took more work to create.

The last card included is E.S. Robinson, Surgeon Dentist, which is a patent medicine trade card advertising dental procedures. This is an interesting card to juxtapose with others because it is simply marketing a service and not a medication which drastically changes the way everything is worded. The services are simply listed with price, no sweeping claims are made. It is unclear if this is just a later card, the choice of the creator to stay simple, or a more highly educated practitioner of medicine. The prices are additionally relatively high for the time period which makes the card likely targeting a more upper-class consumer - affecting what marketing strategies would be more successful. There is still pain control within this advertisement in the form of gas for teeth extraction, which costs extra. There are notably no claims made about this pain control. It is difficult to place this chronologically but it leans towards being a later card within this period.

All these cards do not have a clear date as to when they were created, but language use and marketing strategies offer some strong clues as to their relative time of creation. The shift from miracle "cure alls" to simply advertising a medication that is "for" some ailment is a quick but large shift forward. There are also important differences in strategies between medication advertisements and cards that offer services, the claims or lackthereof are highly contrasting. Much of this can be attibuted to the 1906 Food and Drug Act, but it is not a necessarily a rule if claims are realisitc that it is post-FDA.

This page has paths:

  1. The Children of Medicine: An Appeal to Consumer Emotions Chien-Ling Liu Zeleny

This page references: