Critical Theory in a Digital Age, CCU, ENGL 483 2017

Tabor 2

What do you mean by token girl?
 Token girl/token female  is defined by urbandictionary.com as the one female in an tight-knit group otherwise made up of men (usually the sister or girlfriend of one of the guys in the group though it can also be a female friend of theirs as well). Basically, it's what  Wendy was to the Lost Boys in Peter Pan or what Penny is to Howard, Sheldon, Leonard, and Raj on The Big Bang Theory
This is  mostly a trope that's applied to both film and television, and it is also known as "The Smurfette Principle". It's named after Smurfette, the one lone female in all of Smurf Village on the popular 1980s/1990s cartoon series The Smurfs . The term was first coined by Katia Pollitt in her 1991 New York Times article "The Smurfette Principle" in which she wrote about how having only one solitary female character in a children's television series can send a negative message to its young viewers that 'states' that males can go off and have thrilling adventures while females are a deviation from hat and only exist in relation to the males. This term can be averted or disregarded altogether from a show when and if another female joins the shows primary cast of characters like it happened with The Smurfs when they added another female surf in the form of a little girl smurf named Sassette in its latter seasons. 


 How did this become a socially and culturally accepted thing?
In a 2009 Newsarama article, writer Vaneta Rogers talks about how the term 'geek' was once strictly applied to guys but gradually and recently at events like San Diego more and more women have been in attendance and most of  the men there all seemed to be just fine with it. Yet there were some that were a bit  conflicted about it and debated and put into question the possible sexism of the convention's 'booth babes'  and also let their grievances be known about the increase of fans of a particular series of both books and movies at the time-Twlight (this was 2009 after all). Rogers also goes into a brief 'history' of how the tide of pop culture has shifted from comics and movies that show off superheroes and the events that celebrate them as well as the other aspects of geek culture being exclusively an all guys event to ones for both guys and girls. These days there are some booth babes but not like there was back in 2009, now women are out at these conventions en masse and in full force proudly showing off their geekiness to the world.

To read the whole story about the changing face of fandom (and a bit about the 'booth babes') go here: http://www.today.com/id/32586742/ns/today-today_entertainment/t/emerging-face-geek-fandom-female/#.WiAWEUqnGUk

In this age of female empowerment where young women everywhere are being encouraged to go for their dreams and that they can grow up to be anything they want to be it's become extremely important to show girls that they are as strong and as fierce as any other guy out there no matter what.



What are the drawbacks to this evolution of fandom?
With every sort of change there is a good amount of resistance as well as fear and in the case of the influx of female fans in the 'universes' of Marvel, DC, Stars Wars, and Doctor Who just to name a few there's been such instances.  I am personally not a fan of Doctor Who (aka a "Whovian') but I've seen some of the recoiling some fans have done in response to the idea of the next doctor being a female and it's a bit of a sad sight to see but things like this do occur.  The Learned Fangirl blogger Kendra Chaney also noticed this drawback and discussed it and her personal thoughts when it comes to both this issue and to the whole notion of a fandom and how one belongs to it in her piece " Fandom and Identity/ Fandom as Identity" . In it she discusses how racial and gender identity can play into not only the sense of belonging to a fandom or something belonging to a character based solely on their gender.  Essentially, she is talking about how some parts of pop culture are still seen as being men only in terms of identity while female fans are just there as fans and nothing else. In the article, which you can find and read in its entirety right here:  http://thelearnedfangirl.com/2013/08/fandom-and-identityfandom-as-identity/ , she poses a very good question that those of us in the geek community and as a collective society should ask ourselves- Just because a character fits a certain description- for example white, British male- does that truly mean he only belongs to that sect of the society/fandom culture and no one else with no room or 'hope' for change...OR does he belong to everyone and can be someone other than white, British, male or whatever?
This kind of debate is also going on among fans of the  James Bond franchise when the topic of who should take over the role of 007 when Daniel Craig turns in his Walther PPK and license to kill  is brought up.and it has lead to some heated discussions and debates amongst fans in recent months. Believe me, as a female Bond fan, I've seen it go down on Facebook and YouTube a lot since the last 007 film, "Spectre", came out a couple of years ago. 
No one really likes change even though we get used to i0t regardless of how hard we fought against it. Everything new sometimes becomes the norm over time and such is the case with this fandom world where both men and women can come together and share a love of the same things and pass that on down to the next generation. One such instance of this happened over the summer with the release of "Wonder Woman", a film that was directed by a woman and was about a female superhero..in fact one of the most longstanding and popular heroes out there so it was both refreshing and momentous to see this  film hit the silver screen as hard as it did. both men and women have praised it as being one of the best superhero films ever if not in recent years. Fans young and old have since become inspired by this Amazonian princess and she's continued to be a prime example of what was called 'girl power' back in the '90s only there was nothing cutesy or fluffy about the Wonder woman brand of girl power and it resonated with many a young girl (and even adult women as well). 


Lingering Stigmas & How Females Still Face Them:
However, the stigma of being a female fan in a pop culture world dominated by men is still present today though it's slowly starting to fade away. In her article "Introducing The New Face of Fandom-Women", writer Graeme McMillain shares an anecdote from writer and editor Rachel Edidin about some not too pleasant experience(s) in a comic book store in the following excerpt:  

“I cannot even begin to explain to you the amount of times that I have been at a comic shop or a video game store and men have asked me things like ‘Are you shopping for your boyfriend?'” reports iFanboy contributor and freelance writer Molly McIsaac. “It immediately makes me feel threatened, and feel the need to express my ‘nerd cred,’ which I think is why women are so ridiculously vocal about their fandoms.” Pantozzi agrees, saying that “There is an unfortunate mindset some men have about keeping what’s considered a ‘geek’ to a very small fraction of humanity,” although she points out that “they aren’t the only ones calling women out, other women are as well,” something McIsaac describes as “an aspect of the mean girls club, [but] done more intellectually and passive aggressively.” Such attacks may take the position of centering around fandom credentials, but often have their roots in other social expectations, apparently. “The amount of vitriol I have heard spouted from the female geek community towards other female geeks who don’t have enough ‘cred’ — meaning, too hot to be geeky, or so they think, though they would never say it — is ridiculous,” she says. "
Link to the full article here: 
 http://entertainment.time.com/2012/09/12/introducing-the-new-face-of-fandom-women/

Edidin is talking about how the stereotype of women not being into things like sci-fi, superheroes, and comics is still a lingering entity that females have to deal with whether or not they are even into those things.  Though females are now a big majority of individuals who buy  comic books. We see the 'exotic' girl in a comic book store play out in today's media like in these two scenes from TV's "The Big Bang Theory": 



Even girls reading comics and discussing the 'finer points' of it as well as those 'what if...' questions amongst themselves is something portrayed to comedic effect just like in this other clip from "The Big Bang Theory" where the girls start out discussing it like a book club but then things turn into a complete and total argument between them! 











 

This page references: