Truth-Telling: Frances Willard and Ida B. Wells

6. Willard and Somerset Respond

Ida B. Wells's speech at the BWTA proceeded uneventfully, and the assembly passed an anti-lynching resolution. But not long afterward, Wells's article criticizing Frances Willard appeared in Fraternity, alongside a copy of the Voice interview from 1890.

Shortly thereafter, Lady Somerset sympathetically "interviewed" Willard about her views on race and lynching and her comments from 1890. Her report of this conversation appeared in the London newspaper the Westminster Gazette. It was reprinted in the WCTU's paper, the Union Signal, on June 21, 1894.

After again mentioning her abolitionist upbringing, Willard pointed to an anti-lynching resolution recently passed by the Methodist church in the United States--the denomination to which she belonged. She argued that vigilante justice was not unique to the American South, and that lynchings were far less widespread than Wells's listeners might believe. Due to the importance of "state rights," the national government could only do so much to stop lynchings:

It is really much the same as though London had been held responsible for atrocities in Bulgaria.

Somerset then gave Willard a chance to speak about her comments in 1890. Willard maintained that she had not been talking about lynching at all--only about restricting voting to keep out uneducated people. She repeated her support for an educational test for voting. She and Somerset also drew a parallel between that policy and the British empire keeping Indians from participating in government there.

This page has paths:

Contents of this tag: