America's Pastime: Patent Medicine Trade Cards on Pain

Humor, Harmony, and Healing: Prominent 19th Century Advertising Techniques in Medical Trading Cards

Patent medical trading cards were a prominent way medicine manufacturers could advertise pharmaceutical products directly to the consumer public in the late 19th century. Ephemera such as these serve as artifacts that shed lights on facets of everyday life from the era in which it was produced. Medical historians use trade cards to analyze advertisements for various forms of medications that were used prior to federal regulation. While newspaper ads were dull, easily skimmed over, and costly, trading cards could be distributed directly (often in stores upon purchase), contained colorful designs, and utilized imagery that directly appealed to its audience. In doing so, they promoted “catch-all”, cheap cures to common ailment such as headaches, teething pains, whooping cough, and even cholera. The trading cards examined in this set were selected to highlight three central advertising tactics in the pain-relief market employed between 1870-1906: comedic relief, harmonious family life, and idyllic settings in nature. Distinct imagery would appeal to a wide consumer base all while highlighting that their product was the premier source of pain relief medicine. 

In Brown's trading card that advertises his “Household Panacea”, a homeless man in distressed clothing is carrying a hot boiler through a grassy field. While a burning furnace would be typically too hot to touch with one’s bare hands, the drug is so effective at pain relief that the man is smiling while carrying the burning metal. This, in combination with the attire of the man, paint a rather humorous scene. Many trading cards feature beautiful women in lavish dresses, a far cry from a man in mis-matched shoes and a torn jacket on Brown's card. While one could argue this product is being advertised to all socio-economic classes of society, it is more likely the advertisement was conveying the success of their product through humor. After all, if a man could not feel the burns he was acquiring on his skin using the “Household Panacea”, it certainly would be effective at easing minor pains such as cramps or sprains. Unfortunately, the back of Brown’s card is not a captivating advertisement technique. It lists a set of rules on saving a drowning victim. While this could potentially be helpful, due to the density of text, it is likely one will not read all of the information and opt to just briefly scan over it.
In comparison, “Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup” trading card features a mother reading in bed with two young children. The scene indicates that the soothing qualities of Mrs. Winslow's syrup allows the kids to rest in bed comfortably instead of crying from teething pain. The placement of the bottle on the bedside table indicates that it is a product important to the family. It places the prescription in a realistic setting for easy access. While nothing about this scene is humorous, the setting offers an idyllic image to families currently up for hours at night attempting to sooth their children suffering from teething pain. If they simply purchased “Mrs. Winslow’s Soothing Syrup”, they could be sitting peacefully in bed reading together with their rosy-cheeked, happy children. Similar to Brown’s product, the back of Mrs. Winslow’s card features no information pertaining to the pharmaceutical itself. Rather, it contains another advertisement for a "toilet luxury" product that whitens teeth and protects the gums. This small space for other products reduced the costs of card production, similar to advertisement space in newspapers.

The last card, Ingalls' Throat and Lung Specific, features two boats in the foreground with their sails lowered and a red flag raised, pointing to strong wind warnings. Storm clouds are brewing in the sky, hinting at a possible storm on the horizon. Many medical practitioners believed that time by the sea would clear conditions of the lungs due to the fresh air and salty ocean water. Therefore, it is a promising market technique to associate a medicine for the lungs with time one spends near the ocean or on a sailboat. Accordingly, all three cards promoted their pain medicine through imagery of the aforementioned categories: humor, harmony, or healing settings. 

This page has paths:

  1. Clothing as Tool of Expression: Utilizing Fashion in 19th Century Marketing Chien-Ling Liu Zeleny

This page references: