America's Pastime: Patent Medicine Trade Cards on Pain

The Emotional Side of Medical Marketing: A Historical Analysis of Trading Cards Depicting Younger Patients

As humans, we naturally value those most innocent and valuable to us. In our society, those people are children. A parent could never imagine a tragedy happening to their child, as every parent would be willing to sacrifice their lives for their children to survive.  For my project, I chose three medical training cards; Anchor Pain Expeller, Perry Davis' Pain Killer, and David Nicholson's Liquid Bread. I decided on these three cards because they share a common ideal; it was not necessarily the type of pain killer or illness it cured. However, the marketing of the three images was the same. Furthermore, all my trading cards used the emotional side of marketing to acquire new customers. In two of my trading cards, they portray children; as stated above, children are our society's most innocent, and by marketing to adults, these producers triggered the parents' emotions. Often parents would do anything in their willpower to save their children; placing young children on medical trading cards created a psychological effect that possibly led to parents purchasing the product. In my last trading card, the power of emotional marketing was also used; it was not necessarily used to portray young children but a young adult in pain being cared for. The following three paragraphs will detail my three medical training cards.









In Anchor Pain Expeller, a blacksmith works extremely hard in his shop to produce tools; his surrounding environment indicates poor working conditions. For example, a hot fireplace in the background was needed for the blacksmith-shaped tools. However, this meant the room was likely sweltering when air conditions did not exist. Next, the photo has several extensive tools, such as hammers and axes. In both of the blacksmith's hands, he has heavy tools; by using these tools all day, he is generally expected to be in great pain and agony. Lastly, the younger girl was the first thing that stood out to me. She doesn't have a smile; she doesn't seem too happy as she holds a wooden tray with a glass bottle of ferrola for the blacksmith to take. The producer of this trade card wanted to point out that the girl was in the process of helping out the blacksmith, who very well could have been her father. Additionally, the younger girl seemed innocent and vulnerable to me, and this quickly struck a nerve in consumers.


The following image is Perry Davis' Pain Killer; this medical trading card again emphasizes the issue of exploiting children for medical marketing. As we see in the image, two young children appear to be looking at a chalkboard. The little girl is holding a doll which signals a happy and playful person. The older young boy has school books in his hands. This detail is significant because it emphasizes the importance of a young boy who is currently attending school and is healthy. Adding these props to the children in both cases portrayed innocent and healthy individuals. As they look at the chalkboard, they see "Perry Davis' Pain Killer" along with the phrase "summer & winter" and lastly, "for internal and external use." This product assures parents that with Perry Davis' Pain Killer, their children will be in a safe and suitable environment that is important for their success.


Lastly, we have David Nicholson's Liquid Bread, which is a pure extract of malt; according to the back of the trading card, it was used to treat disease, exhaustion, and insomnia. This medical trading card does not necessarily depict the youth for marketing; however, the core idea of using the younger children was to trigger emotions, sensitivity, and empathy. In this medical trading card, those three ideals are more than emphasized by showing a reasonably young adult woman who is a nun; caring for an ill gentleman. As we see in the trading, the environment looks more lavish than in the other two photos, especially Anchor Pain Expeller. The setting for this trading card features an elegant red chair and wood furniture with a unique finish. Furthermore, in the background, the windows are stained glass, which was expensive at the time. To me, the man is wealthy; however, emotions are still the selling point for David Nicholson's product as he looked to show the man's pain as his arm is in a socket, which no one should ever have to experience.




This page has paths:

  1. The Power of Emotional Marketing: How Vintage Medical Trading Cards Used Children to Sell Their Products to Parents Chien-Ling Liu Zeleny

This page references: