Modern Architectures of North America

Simplicity of program

Though not an asylum, the leprosarium crystallizes the “architectural paradox” of asylums: “[A]sylums should be unassuming and utilitarian, expressing the economic constraints of the state. On the other hand, they might better offer magnificence, thereby enhancing the hospital’s status in society and enticing the public to respect them as civic enterprises” (Yanni 19-20). The notion of “civic enterprise” does not resonate very strongly here because the leprosarium quite deliberately set itself apart from civic engagement; its role, unlike that of, e.g., tuberculosis sanitariums, was not to rehabilitate patients for their eventual return to society, but to isolate them indefinitely. Therefore, Carville was not the sort of high-profile site that required a grand architectural presence to bolster its civic role.

Contents of this annotation:

  1. Anterior facade, administrative building