The Inferiorizing of Nomadic Culture in "The Shadow Beast"
"The Shadow Beast" is about a nomadic person who teaches the narrator of the story about his shadow beast, an animal that is used for travel, shelter, clothing, sustenance, and more. As the rider talks, the narrator makes mental observations: "The nomads are excluded; they are outcasts…In their breasts beat the hearts of beasts…they have never been regarded as part of humanity."The rider says matter-of-factly to the narrator, "Look well into your past and you will know whom God loved." The narrator begins to think about what life was like for Cain, who was forced to live outside of his own people and among the beasts in the wilderness because he was not as good as his brother. After snapping back to reality, the narrator notes that she "felt sweaty, gritty. Longing for a hotel. The rider is right. Cain was the murderer but Abel was the monster."
This final realization points to the idea that because of Abel, nomadic culture became demonized. There is no arguing that Cain was guilty of killing his brother out of jealousy and he is in every way responsible for that action. However, Samatar hints that Abel is the true monster because his lifestyle was the preferred on of God; the product of Cain's labor that he sacrificed was not as good as his brother's, which ultimately made him the lesser brother. God's punishment was sentencing Cain to a nomadic lifestyle instead of a settler one, which inherently paints the former as evil or wrong. However, as the narrator in "The Shadow Beast" learns about the rider's lifestyle she realizes that it is just different from her own, not better or worse. The narrator reiterates that nomadic people are outcasts and seen as inferior by settled society, but as she spends more time with them (and craves the safety of being clean and confined in a hotel) she realizes that she is the inferior one in their culture. But her sudden consciousness of this dichotomy is only that; as the rider points out, there has always been a clear distinction between the two cultures. The idea that settling is not only better, but sanctioned by God, dates back to the story of Cain and Abel and set the precedent for the rest of existence.