This site requires Javascript to be turned on. Please enable Javascript and reload the page.

L.A. Stories: Community Spotlight

The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out

The Southern California chapter of the American Indian Movement (AIM) filed a lawsuit against the City of Malibu for failing to protect Chumash Native American cultural resources. A Malibu landowner complained that he was being charged too much for an archaeological study to be done prior to development of the land he acquired. The City of Malibu relented and granted reduced mitigation measures for the property. The Chumash, in addition to Malibu City’s Archaeologist, were certain that the land contained artifacts and important burial sites from the large Chumash village of Sumo. Read the article “AIM Sues Malibu for Site Approval” for more details (transcript below).

[title] AIM sues Malibu over site approval
[author]P.G. O’Malley, Staff Writer

The Southern California Chapter of the American Indian Movement has filed a lawsuit against Malibu, charging the city with failing to protect Native American cultural resources.
The action is the latest development in an escalating controversy that began in autumn 1994, when Malibu property owner Jack Skene complained he was being charged too much--$46,000—for an in-depth archaeological study by locally based Own Clan Consultants.
The controversy culminated last month then when Malibu City Council approved reduced mitigation measures for Skene’s property.
City Attorney Christi Hogin said the city will fight the suit based on the fact that the Statute of Limitations has run on the original City Council action that allowed Skene the reduced measures. AIM attorney Carol Houck says the suit is based on assertions by City Archaeologist Chester King that Skene’s property contains a site that “may represent he last and best of its kind,” with “artifacts and probably burial sites of tremendous cultural significance to Native Americans.”
In a report to the city, King justified his opinion of the value of the site on research done on other known sites in the area and his own investigation of the site surface.
King did not respond to requests to be interviewed for this story.
Pepperdine archaeologist Dr. Holly Love, who has been following the Skene conflict since the beginning, said, “The only way (King) can make such a claim would be to dig the site. As far as I know, he hasn’t done that. If he has, that means the city archaeologist has been trespassing on private property.”
“We do not know about that site in its age or importance,” said Roberta Greenwood, a 30-year veteran of Southern California excavations, including in Malibu and the city archaeologist for San Juan Capistrano. Greenwood maintained there is no way to characterize a potential site without excavating it, despite what anyone might hypothesize from findings of other related or neighboring sites.
William Bonner, whom Skene sought for a competitive Phase II bid, also challenged King’s assertion of the site as sacred. “There are clearly artifacts on the surface, but nothing that would indicate it’s the last intact site. Dr. King has a different opinion about the historical consequence (of Native American settlement). I don’t know anyone who would back him up.”

[subtitle]‘Got it coming’
Native American A-lil’koy Lotah, secretary of the Malibu Native American Cultural Resources Study Group, has no doubts about the significance of the site, which she says is the last remaining remnant of the Sumo, a Malibu village that reached as far as Point Dume. “It’s sacred because it’s old,” she said.
Asked what should be done with the Skene property, Lotah said she didn’t think anyone should be allowed to live on it and that perhaps the city should buy it or Skene should donate it.
“I think AIM is doing the right thing. Jack Skene has caused a lot of people hurt. He put native people against each other. He’s got it coming,” she said.

This page has paths:

Los Angeles has long been multicultural, with peoples of different backgrounds finding a home and a place to create community. The stories told here spotlight communities little featured in traditional narratives of the city and county history. They include activism by the Chumash people, who predate California as a state, seeking to ensure the continuity and visibility of their history in Malibu. It also includes stories of African-American communities, Japanese-American communities, and activists defending the rights of day-laborers and street-vendors.
Contents of this path:
1. The Bank of Finance The Bank of Finance (2651 S. Western Avenue) was the first state-chartered, black-owned commercial bank in Los Angeles. It was established by Onie B. Granville, a local real estate broker who was frustrated by his clients’ difficulties in obtaining home loans and the discriminatory practices they faced when attempting to purchase property west of Western Avenue. Here, vault teller Dolores Anne Alfter is shown assisting a customer at the bank.
2. Christopher St. West The first-ever U.S. gay pride parade was held in Los Angeles in June 1970, on the one-year anniversary of the Stonewall Riots on Christopher Street in NYC. It was the only “street closing” gay pride parade held that year. This poster promotes the second Christopher St. West parade held in L.A. No offset printer was willing to print it until organizers contacted Peace Press, a workers’ collective founded by anti-Vietnam War activists in 1967.
3. Cross Burning is Racist Terror-Stop the Klan This poster documents the 1983 burning of three crosses in Kagel Canyon, an ethnically diverse community in Los Angeles County. This was the first known collaboration in U.S. history of the Ku Klux Klan, the Aryan Nation and the U.S. Nazis. Fifteen Neo-Nazis and Klan members were initially charged, but only 4 were ultimately tried and convicted in 1991, including Tom Metzger, a former KKK Grand Dragon and founder of the White Aryan Resistance.
4. Happening House: 102 East Indigo Street Front of Happening House: 102 East Indigo Street; white house with a green roof; the sign reads 'Communicative Arts Academy' in front of the house to the right of the front door; a person sitting on a chair under the front door roof; some garbage in the left foreground and a yellow fireplug right of the center foreground; a tree and lawn.
  
  The Compton Communicative Arts Academy was one expression of a vibrant community arts movement that developed in Los Angeles and other U.S. cities during the late 1960s. In L.A., this movement included Self-Help Graphics and the mural program that became SPARC, among other groups. The community arts movement opposed the elite and Eurocentric biases of the City’s dominant artistic institutions and the nearly wholesale exclusion of artists of color from exhibits, galleries, and museums. Participants believed that all people need and deserve expressive outlets, that art can be a powerful force for positive social change, and that the arts are vital to the building of strong communities.
5. Musical performance in courtyard of the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion Performance in the courtyard of the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion fountain; one trumpet player standing; a man playing a maraca; one man playing the flute; other musicians in the background.
  
  The Compton Communicative Arts Academy was one expression of a vibrant community arts movement that developed in Los Angeles and other U.S. cities during the late 1960s. In L.A., this movement included Self-Help Graphics and the mural program that became SPARC, among other groups. The community arts movement opposed the elite and Eurocentric biases of the City’s dominant artistic institutions and the nearly wholesale exclusion of artists of color from exhibits, galleries, and museums. Participants believed that all people need and deserve expressive outlets, that art can be a powerful force for positive social change, and that the arts are vital to the building of strong communities.
6. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out
7. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out The Southern California chapter of the American Indian Movement (AIM) filed a lawsuit against the City of Malibu for failing to protect Chumash Native American cultural resources. A Malibu landowner complained that he was being charged too much for an archaeological study to be done prior to development of the land he acquired. The City of Malibu relented and granted reduced mitigation measures for the property. The Chumash, in addition to Malibu City’s Archaeologist, were certain that the land contained artifacts and important burial sites from the large Chumash village of Sumo. Read the article “AIM Sues Malibu for Site Approval” for more details (transcript below).
  
  [title] AIM sues Malibu over site approval
  [author]P.G. O’Malley, Staff Writer
  
  The Southern California Chapter of the American Indian Movement has filed a lawsuit against Malibu, charging the city with failing to protect Native American cultural resources.
  The action is the latest development in an escalating controversy that began in autumn 1994, when Malibu property owner Jack Skene complained he was being charged too much--$46,000—for an in-depth archaeological study by locally based Own Clan Consultants.
  The controversy culminated last month then when Malibu City Council approved reduced mitigation measures for Skene’s property.
  City Attorney Christi Hogin said the city will fight the suit based on the fact that the Statute of Limitations has run on the original City Council action that allowed Skene the reduced measures. AIM attorney Carol Houck says the suit is based on assertions by City Archaeologist Chester King that Skene’s property contains a site that “may represent he last and best of its kind,” with “artifacts and probably burial sites of tremendous cultural significance to Native Americans.”
  In a report to the city, King justified his opinion of the value of the site on research done on other known sites in the area and his own investigation of the site surface.
  King did not respond to requests to be interviewed for this story.
  Pepperdine archaeologist Dr. Holly Love, who has been following the Skene conflict since the beginning, said, “The only way (King) can make such a claim would be to dig the site. As far as I know, he hasn’t done that. If he has, that means the city archaeologist has been trespassing on private property.”
  “We do not know about that site in its age or importance,” said Roberta Greenwood, a 30-year veteran of Southern California excavations, including in Malibu and the city archaeologist for San Juan Capistrano. Greenwood maintained there is no way to characterize a potential site without excavating it, despite what anyone might hypothesize from findings of other related or neighboring sites.
  William Bonner, whom Skene sought for a competitive Phase II bid, also challenged King’s assertion of the site as sacred. “There are clearly artifacts on the surface, but nothing that would indicate it’s the last intact site. Dr. King has a different opinion about the historical consequence (of Native American settlement). I don’t know anyone who would back him up.”
  
  [subtitle]‘Got it coming’
  Native American A-lil’koy Lotah, secretary of the Malibu Native American Cultural Resources Study Group, has no doubts about the significance of the site, which she says is the last remaining remnant of the Sumo, a Malibu village that reached as far as Point Dume. “It’s sacred because it’s old,” she said.
  Asked what should be done with the Skene property, Lotah said she didn’t think anyone should be allowed to live on it and that perhaps the city should buy it or Skene should donate it.
  “I think AIM is doing the right thing. Jack Skene has caused a lot of people hurt. He put native people against each other. He’s got it coming,” she said.
8. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out The Southern California chapter of the American Indian Movement (AIM) filed a lawsuit against the City of Malibu for failing to protect Chumash Native American cultural resources. A Malibu landowner complained that he was being charged too much for an archaeological study to be done prior to development of the land he acquired. The City of Malibu relented and granted reduced mitigation measures for the property. The Chumash, in addition to Malibu City’s Archaeologist, were certain that the land contained artifacts and important burial sites from the large Chumash village of Sumo. Read the article “AIM Sues Malibu for Site Approval” for more details (transcript below).
  
  [title] AIM sues Malibu over site approval
  [author]P.G. O’Malley, Staff Writer
  
  The Southern California Chapter of the American Indian Movement has filed a lawsuit against Malibu, charging the city with failing to protect Native American cultural resources.
  The action is the latest development in an escalating controversy that began in autumn 1994, when Malibu property owner Jack Skene complained he was being charged too much--$46,000—for an in-depth archaeological study by locally based Own Clan Consultants.
  The controversy culminated last month then when Malibu City Council approved reduced mitigation measures for Skene’s property.
  City Attorney Christi Hogin said the city will fight the suit based on the fact that the Statute of Limitations has run on the original City Council action that allowed Skene the reduced measures. AIM attorney Carol Houck says the suit is based on assertions by City Archaeologist Chester King that Skene’s property contains a site that “may represent he last and best of its kind,” with “artifacts and probably burial sites of tremendous cultural significance to Native Americans.”
  In a report to the city, King justified his opinion of the value of the site on research done on other known sites in the area and his own investigation of the site surface.
  King did not respond to requests to be interviewed for this story.
  Pepperdine archaeologist Dr. Holly Love, who has been following the Skene conflict since the beginning, said, “The only way (King) can make such a claim would be to dig the site. As far as I know, he hasn’t done that. If he has, that means the city archaeologist has been trespassing on private property.”
  “We do not know about that site in its age or importance,” said Roberta Greenwood, a 30-year veteran of Southern California excavations, including in Malibu and the city archaeologist for San Juan Capistrano. Greenwood maintained there is no way to characterize a potential site without excavating it, despite what anyone might hypothesize from findings of other related or neighboring sites.
  William Bonner, whom Skene sought for a competitive Phase II bid, also challenged King’s assertion of the site as sacred. “There are clearly artifacts on the surface, but nothing that would indicate it’s the last intact site. Dr. King has a different opinion about the historical consequence (of Native American settlement). I don’t know anyone who would back him up.”
  
  [subtitle]‘Got it coming’
  Native American A-lil’koy Lotah, secretary of the Malibu Native American Cultural Resources Study Group, has no doubts about the significance of the site, which she says is the last remaining remnant of the Sumo, a Malibu village that reached as far as Point Dume. “It’s sacred because it’s old,” she said.
  Asked what should be done with the Skene property, Lotah said she didn’t think anyone should be allowed to live on it and that perhaps the city should buy it or Skene should donate it.
  “I think AIM is doing the right thing. Jack Skene has caused a lot of people hurt. He put native people against each other. He’s got it coming,” she said.
9. Oedipus Motorcycle Club Royal Dinner Members of the Oedipus Motorcycle Club pose in front of club banners at a Royal Dinner to honor the “coronation” of the new leader of the club, called Oedipus Rex. The men are all in their formal club uniforms of white vests and black shirts, some with sashes, medals, or pins. The Oedipus Rex and his court (back row, center) also wear white capes.
  
  The Oedipus Motorcycle Club was founded in 1958 is the second oldest gay motorcycle club in Los Angeles. The club was founded for the purpose of providing a welcoming environment for riders in gay communities, offering them a sanctuary where they could comfortably gather in groups without fear of persecution. Similar clubs continue their tradition to this day with monthly rides, promoting safe riding, and socializing for gay riders.
10. Kicheko Davis Discusses the First Celebration of Kwanzaa In this oral history interview audio clip, Kicheko Davis, a former member of the US organization discusses the why, how, and where of how she and fellow members of the organization created the now-internationally celebrated African American holiday, Kwanzaa.
  
  Kwanzaa is celebrated around the world most people are unaware of its Los Angeles origins. Or that it was created by the members of US, a black Nationalist organization located in Los Angeles.
11. Central Avenue street scene, Los Angeles, circa 1940s One African American man and six boys stand at the corner of Central Avenue and East Vernon Avenue. Across the street is the California Bank building with the dental office of Dr. J. G. Hatcher on the second floor. Central Avenue is a major north-south thoroughfare in the Los Angeles metropolitan area. From 1920 to 1955, it was the heart of the African-American community, with active rhythm and blues and jazz music scenes.
12. Central Avenue African American Couple Dancing, 1938
13. Five Star Liquor Store Central Avenue 1940s The Five Star Liquor Store was located at 4625 Central Avenue in Los Angeles, California. In the picture are (left to right: Leonard Senters, Clara Senters, an unidentified man, and an unidentified woman (possibly Hazel Senters). Central Avenue is a major north-south thoroughfare in the Los Angeles metropolitan area. From 1920 to 1955, it was the heart of the African-American community, with active rhythm and blues and jazz music scenes.
14. Former US member Kicheko Davis
15. Civil engineer Carlos Sebastian Lorente, and sculptor Sergio López-Mesa installing the José Martí monument in Echo Park, at José Martí Square, 1976. Ties between the Cuban community and Echo Park can be traced back more than sixty years. In the early 1960s, 14,000 exiled Cubans moved to Los Angeles and many settled in Echo Park, creating businesses, newspapers, and clubs. Known then as “Little Havana,” it was a gathering place for Cuban émigrés’ celebrations and anti-Castro protests. Still memorializing the cultural heritage of the Cuban community is the monument erected in 1976 of poet and patriot José Martí, by sculptor Sergio Lopez-Mesa (a replica is in USC’s Doheny Library).
16. VC's Ghetto-Style Camera Harness As inelegant as it was inventive, this handmade camera harness was developed by Visual Communications staffers in early 1979 to allow hand-held photography using VC's workhorse motion picture camera, the Eclair NPR — a 16mm camera that, with a 400-foot film magazine, could weigh as much as 40 pounds. This harness was put into service by cinematographers Dale Iwamasa and Takashi Fujii for VC's feature-length drama HITO HATA: RAISE THE BANNER.
  
  This home-made steadicam exemplifies the resourcefulness and invention that characterized Visual Communications' approach to grassroots mediamaking. As an organization operating on a shoestring budget, the need to "make things work" with little money is evidenced in this item and its impact on the organization's work. Since its founding in 1970, Visual Communications has produced films, provided support services for Asian American artists and filmmakers, workshops and trainings for the community, and more presentation opportunities for independent media in Los Angeles.
17. Technal A-I 650 Print Dryer Little-used since its acquisition by Visual Communications in the mid-1980s, the Technal A-I Model 650 sat unused while prints were air-dried on wire racks. However, it proved a valuable asset in 2009, when water damage threatened a recent acquisition — the 85,000-image collection of the late Eddie Oshiro, a photo hobbyist whose collection was inherited by VC in 2007. The Technal 650 proved indispensible as assets were cleaned and preserved from possible loss due to flooding.
  
  While the vast majority of Visual Communications' darkroom photography involved air-drying prints made from negatives and slides, this electric dryer played a little-known but vital role in rescuing a photo collection that was threatened by water damage. Since its founding in 1970, Visual Communications has produced films, provided support services for Asian American artists and filmmakers, workshops and trainings for the community, and more presentation opportunities for independent media in Los Angeles.
18. CWRIC Hearing Tapes 1981 In order to amplify the previously unknown stories of Japanese Americans whose lives were impacted by forced relocation and incarceration during WWII, Visual Communications and the National Coalition for Redress & Reparations made available highlights of the L.A. Hearings of the Commission on Wartime Relocation and Internment of Civilians (CWRIC). The tapes, mastered on uMatic broadcast video, were screened at various community events and helped to win public favor for monetary redress in 1988.
  
  The tapes pictured here went missing from Visual Communications' Archive for many decades, and have only recently been unearthed in San Diego and returned to the organization. Since its founding in 1970, Visual Communications has produced films, provided support services for Asian American artists and filmmakers, workshops and trainings for the community, and more presentation opportunities for independent media in Los Angeles.
19. Hay Milliones de Rostros Como Este This cartoon-like print, whose title translates to “there are millions of faces like this,” depicts a drawing of a “jornalero” or day laborer whose portrait consists of dozens of smaller faces. The faces are men and women, young and old, expressing joy, defeat, and everything in between. The raised fist in the top of the hat places the print in the context of worker and communal solidarity, making the ordinary jornalero a reflection of the unity and alliance among Latino workers throughout the nation.
20. Jornaleros en la Lucha
21. Vendedores En Acción #StreetVendorsDoc As part of Art Rise/WE RISE initiative, Self Help Graphics & Art presents Vendedores en Acción (Vendors in Action or VEA), a short documentary directed by Alvaro Parra, following six street vendors and also leaders of the VEA coalition of Los Angeles. The film highlights the long-term mental and emotional implications caused by their line of work, their fight to legalize street vending, and economic insecurity amplified by COVID-19.
22. New Officers for PV Woman's Club Newly elected club officers for the 1954-1955 season, with retiring president Mrs. Thomas King at center. In addition to a President, Vice President, Treasurer and Secretary, the Club also noted new representatives for the following sections: Book, Garden, Public Services Workshop, Bridge, Properties, Red Cross, Hospitality, Tea and Press Representative. The Club’s activities ranged from cultural and philanthropic events to church and civic affairs for the developing community.
  
  The Palos Verdes Women's Club, started in 1926, contributed in a number of ways to the development of the Palos Verdes Peninsula.
23. California Federation of Women’s Club award luncheon Started in 1960, the Rolling Hills Estates Woman’s Club became part of the California Federation of Women’s Club in 1962. Like the Palos Verdes Women’s Club, it dedicated itself to public welfare, civic engagement and philanthropic projects. It sponsored volunteer service organizations for high school girls and contributed financially to local organizations including Toberman Settlement House, Rainbow Services for Battered Women, South Coast Botanic Gardens, the Norris Theatre Building Fund and Harbor Interfaith Shelter.

This page has tags:

Pepperdine University's Special Collections and University Archives maintains several collections of materials related to the history of Los Angeles. The Malibu Historical Collection includes a full run of the Malibu Times newspaper (1946-present), a full run of the the Malibu Surfside News newspaper (1973-present), the John Mazza Collection of Historic Surfboards, historic books related to Malibu and its residents, audio recordings of lectures on Malibu history, and records of the Malibu Water Company, the Rindge Dam, and the Malibu Stage Company. The James Hahn Collection (1990-2005) includes materials from Hahn's years as mayor of Los Angeles and as Los Angeles City Attorney. The Elinor Oswald Collection of Los Angeles Tourism Ephemera includes brochures, pamphlets, and newspaper clippings related to museums, art galleries, and artists in the Los Angeles area. The William S. Banowsky Papers and the M. Norvel Young Papers include materials related to various civic and political events in the Los Angeles area that occurred during their tenures as Pepperdine presidents. The Pepperdine University Archives includes photographs, audio and video, publications, and institutional records that document the history of the institution from its founding in 1937 in South Central Los Angeles, to its move to Malibu in 1972, to the present time.

https://library.pepperdine.edu/collections/special-collections/
Contents of this tag:
1. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out The Southern California chapter of the American Indian Movement (AIM) filed a lawsuit against the City of Malibu for failing to protect Chumash Native American cultural resources. A Malibu landowner complained that he was being charged too much for an archaeological study to be done prior to development of the land he acquired. The City of Malibu relented and granted reduced mitigation measures for the property. The Chumash, in addition to Malibu City’s Archaeologist, were certain that the land contained artifacts and important burial sites from the large Chumash village of Sumo. Read the article “AIM Sues Malibu for Site Approval” for more details (transcript below).
  
  [title] AIM sues Malibu over site approval
  [author]P.G. O’Malley, Staff Writer
  
  The Southern California Chapter of the American Indian Movement has filed a lawsuit against Malibu, charging the city with failing to protect Native American cultural resources.
  The action is the latest development in an escalating controversy that began in autumn 1994, when Malibu property owner Jack Skene complained he was being charged too much--$46,000—for an in-depth archaeological study by locally based Own Clan Consultants.
  The controversy culminated last month then when Malibu City Council approved reduced mitigation measures for Skene’s property.
  City Attorney Christi Hogin said the city will fight the suit based on the fact that the Statute of Limitations has run on the original City Council action that allowed Skene the reduced measures. AIM attorney Carol Houck says the suit is based on assertions by City Archaeologist Chester King that Skene’s property contains a site that “may represent he last and best of its kind,” with “artifacts and probably burial sites of tremendous cultural significance to Native Americans.”
  In a report to the city, King justified his opinion of the value of the site on research done on other known sites in the area and his own investigation of the site surface.
  King did not respond to requests to be interviewed for this story.
  Pepperdine archaeologist Dr. Holly Love, who has been following the Skene conflict since the beginning, said, “The only way (King) can make such a claim would be to dig the site. As far as I know, he hasn’t done that. If he has, that means the city archaeologist has been trespassing on private property.”
  “We do not know about that site in its age or importance,” said Roberta Greenwood, a 30-year veteran of Southern California excavations, including in Malibu and the city archaeologist for San Juan Capistrano. Greenwood maintained there is no way to characterize a potential site without excavating it, despite what anyone might hypothesize from findings of other related or neighboring sites.
  William Bonner, whom Skene sought for a competitive Phase II bid, also challenged King’s assertion of the site as sacred. “There are clearly artifacts on the surface, but nothing that would indicate it’s the last intact site. Dr. King has a different opinion about the historical consequence (of Native American settlement). I don’t know anyone who would back him up.”
  
  [subtitle]‘Got it coming’
  Native American A-lil’koy Lotah, secretary of the Malibu Native American Cultural Resources Study Group, has no doubts about the significance of the site, which she says is the last remaining remnant of the Sumo, a Malibu village that reached as far as Point Dume. “It’s sacred because it’s old,” she said.
  Asked what should be done with the Skene property, Lotah said she didn’t think anyone should be allowed to live on it and that perhaps the city should buy it or Skene should donate it.
  “I think AIM is doing the right thing. Jack Skene has caused a lot of people hurt. He put native people against each other. He’s got it coming,” she said.
2. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out The Southern California chapter of the American Indian Movement (AIM) filed a lawsuit against the City of Malibu for failing to protect Chumash Native American cultural resources. A Malibu landowner complained that he was being charged too much for an archaeological study to be done prior to development of the land he acquired. The City of Malibu relented and granted reduced mitigation measures for the property. The Chumash, in addition to Malibu City’s Archaeologist, were certain that the land contained artifacts and important burial sites from the large Chumash village of Sumo. Read the article “AIM Sues Malibu for Site Approval” for more details (transcript below).
  
  [title] AIM sues Malibu over site approval
  [author]P.G. O’Malley, Staff Writer
  
  The Southern California Chapter of the American Indian Movement has filed a lawsuit against Malibu, charging the city with failing to protect Native American cultural resources.
  The action is the latest development in an escalating controversy that began in autumn 1994, when Malibu property owner Jack Skene complained he was being charged too much--$46,000—for an in-depth archaeological study by locally based Own Clan Consultants.
  The controversy culminated last month then when Malibu City Council approved reduced mitigation measures for Skene’s property.
  City Attorney Christi Hogin said the city will fight the suit based on the fact that the Statute of Limitations has run on the original City Council action that allowed Skene the reduced measures. AIM attorney Carol Houck says the suit is based on assertions by City Archaeologist Chester King that Skene’s property contains a site that “may represent he last and best of its kind,” with “artifacts and probably burial sites of tremendous cultural significance to Native Americans.”
  In a report to the city, King justified his opinion of the value of the site on research done on other known sites in the area and his own investigation of the site surface.
  King did not respond to requests to be interviewed for this story.
  Pepperdine archaeologist Dr. Holly Love, who has been following the Skene conflict since the beginning, said, “The only way (King) can make such a claim would be to dig the site. As far as I know, he hasn’t done that. If he has, that means the city archaeologist has been trespassing on private property.”
  “We do not know about that site in its age or importance,” said Roberta Greenwood, a 30-year veteran of Southern California excavations, including in Malibu and the city archaeologist for San Juan Capistrano. Greenwood maintained there is no way to characterize a potential site without excavating it, despite what anyone might hypothesize from findings of other related or neighboring sites.
  William Bonner, whom Skene sought for a competitive Phase II bid, also challenged King’s assertion of the site as sacred. “There are clearly artifacts on the surface, but nothing that would indicate it’s the last intact site. Dr. King has a different opinion about the historical consequence (of Native American settlement). I don’t know anyone who would back him up.”
  
  [subtitle]‘Got it coming’
  Native American A-lil’koy Lotah, secretary of the Malibu Native American Cultural Resources Study Group, has no doubts about the significance of the site, which she says is the last remaining remnant of the Sumo, a Malibu village that reached as far as Point Dume. “It’s sacred because it’s old,” she said.
  Asked what should be done with the Skene property, Lotah said she didn’t think anyone should be allowed to live on it and that perhaps the city should buy it or Skene should donate it.
  “I think AIM is doing the right thing. Jack Skene has caused a lot of people hurt. He put native people against each other. He’s got it coming,” she said.
3. The Chumash of Malibu Speak Out