The Varieties and Complexities of American Handwriting and Penmanship: Library Hand

Thomas Edison, John Jackson, Mevil Dewey, and Early Vertical Writing

Born in 1847, Edison grew up at a time when writing was continuing to evolve and change, when writing styles were being introduced by many dozens of different authors and publishers. It is interesting to note that while the writing of his boyhood is not entirely unusual, it does not represent the norm of a forward slanted joined script of the more educated and practiced writers of the day. 

Although I have not seen much of Edison's early writing, it is fair to say that he had a mixed style of a backhanded cursive mixed with some lettering in the samples I have seen from 1862. 

http://davidkaminski.org/wiki/Thomas_Alva_Edison,_Letter_to_Willis_D_Engle,_page_1,_1862

As a telegraph clerk trying to write faster and more legibly, Edison developed a manuscript print style, and it was a style that was perpetuated among and imitated by other telegraph clerks.

While Edison's style remains largely unacknowledged in books on the history of penmanship, it clearly is upright, unlike the style of the time. However, it is fair to say that he neither authored a book on penmanship nor taught it in any institutions, and so he cannot be seen as among those who influenced the nation's youth nor the broader public. 

By contrast, one can point to the next iteration of a vertical style that was widely promoted with great vigor and purported to be backed by scientific studies. Writing teachers in Europe first adopted it, and later it came to be popularized by John Jackson in England in the 1880's. While it is hard to find the exact date that Jackson's vertical style came to be known by those in the United States, there is evidence that it was not later than 1887. Here, one can see an advertisement of it in The Educational Times


The history of vertical writing, as it comes from the Europeans and John Jackson extends into Canada with Newlands and Row in Canada as early adopters there; Vaile and Harison as early adopters in the US; and many others later from roughly 1894 - 1904, at which point the trend reversed itself.

However, news of Edison's style, present since the late 1860s, and his efforts did, however, reach Melvil Dewey, who was perhaps inspired by Edison. Melvil later introduces "library hand," itself a vertical style, as the official style to be used by all librarians. Like Edison, he was interested in speed, efficiency, and legibility. One can think of the vertical style as the handwritten equivalent to the typewriter, which was rapidly evolving as a fast and efficient office machine that created its own vertical print. 


However, likely neither Edison nor Dewey would have probably approved of the evolution of their vertical script ideals. In many writers, vertical script evolves into a backhand style. Here is a library card written for a gift received in 1909. This particular script has the worst qualities of being somewhat ornate, which Edison had avoided; it is also not in Dewey's prescribed style. And of course, it is harder to read since it is both slanted, and slanted backwards. Oh, progress!


This page references: