Master of Puppets: MUSIC 1701 Final Project

Introduction

In 1986, mainstream music focused on providing escapism and were made by bands that prioritized commercial appeal. Metallica, on the other hand, was the complete opposite. Rather than escapism, they promoted facing your problems head on. They never played it safe—their attitude was completely rebellious. The band was the definition of thrash, the genre of music they pulled from the underground into the mainstream. As Jake Brennan describes it, Metallica was “Fast. Tight. Metal. Real” (Brennan, 13:57).

“Master of Puppets” was a song that propelled Metallica's career. The track epitomized rebellion and social consciousness as Metallica defied mainstream norms by warning against the dangers of drug dependence. Everything about the song was bold—from its subject matter to its distortion to its unconventional length.

The song’s boldness was a direct reflection of its creators, who each had bold personalities and ideas in their own personal ways. "The Men Behind Metallica: Biographies and Inspirations" is a set of short biographies that describe the lives, influences, and musical backgrounds of each band member to show how they shaped Metallica. Each member's experiences shaped them into unapologetic, authentic artists who not only wrote great songs but also confronted uncomfortable truths. Their punk attitudes shine through, as described in both "Power Chords and Protest: How Metallica Reflected a Generation of Rebellious Listeners" and "From Escapism to Impact: How Metallica Paved the Way for Music with Meaning."

In "From Escapism to Impact: How Metallica Paved the Way for Music with Meaning," I analyze how Metallica set themselves apart from mainstream music in their time, which I achieve by discussing how their subject matter and the feelings they tried to evoke were different from others. Their music delved into socially relevant themes, like addiction, and channeled the aggression from their listeners into a desire for rebellion. Others also say that Metallica set themselves apart by not being hypermasculine, but author Gareth Heritage disproves their ideas, saying that they present masculinity through their aggression instead of the misogyny that was characteristic of other '80s bands. Although Metallica set themselves apart by avoiding hatred and supremacy in their lyrics, this was not always the case for their fan base. Dave Everley critiques the metal community for its exclusionary tendencies, especially regarding race. He notes, “For a genre that prides itself on its outsider status, metal can be unwelcoming to anyone whose face doesn’t fit” (Everley). This criticism adds another layer to the conversation about how Metallica's music was more socially progressive than other bands by discussing how their message and ideals are not always reflected in their fans.

The songs at the beginning of the playlist "The Sound of Social Change" represent the songs at the time, which focused on being fun and providing an escape from reality, encouraging the audience to forget their issues rather than face them. In Brown’s article, he talks about how the fame of Metallica represents their listeners who faced societal challenges and wanted attention to be called to those challenges, unlike mainstream music with less meaningful lyrics at the time.

In "Power Chords and Protest: How Metallica Reflected a Generation of Rebellious Listeners," I focus on what sets Metallica apart from other bands and their contribution to the rise of heavy metal. Metallica’s cultural impact can be observed through the shifting demographics over time. Andy Brown used the Rolling Stone’s ratings over time to argue that Metallica grew in popularity because they appealed to feelings that people believed in. Like me, Brown was interested in how Metallica stood out from bands at the time and how they affected the rest of the world.  Since Metallica’s messages were targeted against societal issues and their vocals were very indignant, it was likely easy for rebellious youth to identify with them. The amount of support that Metallica received thus reflects a large demographic of listeners: people who wanted a better world and wanted music with meaning.

"Master of Puppets Review: A Warning Against the Chains of Addiction" dives deeper into the issue that “Master of Puppets” is about and how Metallica went about expressing its significance. I examine how Metallica used different lyrical and instrumental elements to convey a sense of seriousness in their song, making it a grave warning about drug addiction. They created an evil sound that mirrored the darker themes of addiction and they presented a cautionary tale that warned the listeners about the consequences. The music is important because it is a warning, and the review discusses how Metallica creates that warning to make it appear serious. It also discusses the relevance of this warning. Drug issues were prevalent at the time of the song's release. Amber Matheson looks back on this, saying, "The ’80s had their own brand of fuel to keep the party going, too: cocaine" (Matheson).

In "The Heart of Metal: Metallica’s Guitar and Bass Techniques," I analyze aspects of the instrumentals of “Master of Puppets” that are less relevant to the arguments being made in "Master of Puppets Review: A Warning Against the Chains of Addiction". It focuses solely on the musical elements because good music conveys its message through its sound. As Robert Walser puts it, “musical codes are the primary bearers of meaning” (40). These instrumentals are what made Metallica’s music “heavy”, but Jason Miller notes that “heaviness” can be difficult to articulate (Miller).

The significance of “Master of Puppets” lies in the band's willingness to tackle relevant cultural issues and send a warning. This is particularly important in the context mainstream '80s music, which often focused on escapism and commercial safety. The song forces listeners to face the dark realities of addiction and invites them to rebel in a display of aggression—an uncommon approach at the time. Through their work, Metallica pioneered the genre of thrash metal and paved the way for other bands to deal with serious subjects in their songs.




 

This page has paths:

  1. Master of Puppets Kaylee Ulep