Ghawazi Dancer
1 2016-05-07T15:59:02-07:00 Zainab Ali f268dc3d52314675a80939ff2b52a3fc15a80a1e 8178 1 A ghawazi dancer performs with musicians for a man and woman plain 2016-05-07T15:59:02-07:00 Zainab Ali f268dc3d52314675a80939ff2b52a3fc15a80a1eThis page is referenced by:
-
1
2016-05-05T01:24:07-07:00
Zainab's Introduction: Shaping Identity Through the Past and Present
29
Final Project
gallery
281540
2016-05-09T20:37:49-07:00
In Miral al-Tahawy's "Brooklyn Heights," modernity plays a huge role, which changes the characters' lives. Traveling used to be more about the journey than the destination, because it would take so long to reach faraway places, but for Hend, who uses a flight to take her son and herself to New York from Egypt, the journey is not even mentioned. This lack of a solid bridge between her two lifestyles results in less time for her to be mentally prepared for the culture shock she faces in her new environment, and thus, her story focuses on her destination after coming from the airport. Unprepared for what is to come, Hend falls into depression.
Hend constantly creates parallels between her past in Egypt and her present in America as she struggles to establish a new home for herself in a foreign country. She tries to hold on to her memories desperately to try to define her identity, which proves to be ambiguous. She introduces herself as Egyptian, but as she recalls, others view her as a solely Bedouin. She lives in America now, but she doesn't think of herself as American yet. She is a Muslim, but she shrinks from religion and prefers to talk of the zodiac.
Other people's journeys are embedded in the memory of Hend's past, which relate to her own history. The histories of three people in Hend's life- the Guest, Zuba, and Hend's father- reflect journeys made to a new place (either in location or lifestyle or a combination of the two). All three show how their past and origins are not completely lost or forgotten with the change of time and place.
-
1
2016-05-07T15:15:08-07:00
Zainab's Conclusion for Final Project
2
plain
281540
2016-05-07T16:00:12-07:00
In the three lives of the people that were a part of Hend's life in "Brooklyn Heights," important elements of the past are still retained by the Guest, Zuba, and Hend's father even as the time and place dramatically changes for them. They adapt to their new surroundings and lifestyles, yet continue their lives with the implementation of components of their heritage and origin in a new setting. Keeping alive key concepts from their past is important to each of these characters, and they hold on to them proudly, because it shapes their identity. The concept of identity is ambiguous, as Bedouins are not seen as Egyptians, while Hend does; ghawazi dancers are seen as gypsies, which might not be entirely true; and the Copts' distinction as Christians becomes secondary as they are sucked into the nationalistic label of being an Arab, which misguidingly has a Muslim connotation. The three characters try to overcome the vagueness of identity by holding onto their past to create a sense of solidity in themselves.
This balance between the past and present is what Hend tries so desperately to achieve in the novel. She feels that in this new environment in New York and the start of this new chapter in her life is too different of an experience and it may take away her identity. Therefore, she constantly tries to create parallels between her life in Egypt with her new life in America to find a thread of continuation that she can hold on to and not lose her identity while in transition. In Hend's case, she is unable to find this balance, since her depression keeps her mind in the past while she struggles to find an ideal niche for herself in Brooklyn. Hend avoids talking to Naguib in Arabic, yet she does not stop talking about her life in Egypt with Charlie, which shows her inability to find the correct balance between her past and present that create her identity.
This identity crisis contrasts with the Guest, Zuba, and Hend's father's strong personalities, which they create through holding on to ideas of their origin while also taking on new roles in a shifting landscape.